Life seems easy for the little red tuna crabs delighting Monterey Bay Aquarium visitors. The temperature and water chemistry in their exhibit are carefully controlled and stable. In the wild, it’s a different story. Conditions are changing—fast. Crabs and other critters are in a race with time, as record levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) warm the planet and change ocean chemistry.
Our colleagues at the Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI) are on the front line, documenting the impacts and identifying potential solutions for this serious threat to ocean health.
CO2 bubbled up slowly
For more than a century, scientists have known that burning fossil fuels warms our planet. They’ve also long been aware of another impact—this one affecting ocean chemistry.
In 1909, a chemist at the Carlsberg Brewery Laboratory discovered that CO2 dissolved in water not only creates tiny bubbles (like in beer). It also makes liquid more acidic. In other words, our burning of fossil fuels is changing the chemistry of the ocean, a process called ocean acidification.
The impact of rising atmospheric CO2 developed slowly and subtly. By the 1960s, however, climatologists began raising alarms. Decades later, Al Gore’s landmark book and movie, An Inconvenient Truth, framed climate change as an urgent threat to human survival. As the scientific community worked to build accurate models of climate dynamics and explore ways to deal with rampant carbon, some eyed the ocean—which absorbs 25 percent to 30 percent of the excess CO2 in the atmosphere—as a solution. Could we stash even more atmospheric carbon in the sea, sparing the planet the worst impacts of global warming?
MBARI chemist Peter Brewer and his colleague, ocean ecologist Jim Barry, saw a scientific opportunity to study the impacts of a more carbonated sea. “Peter worked out how we could take CO2 down to the seabed and observe its behavior and chemistry,” Jim recalls.
During the late 1990s and early 2000s, the pair lowered containers of liquid CO2 to the floor of the deep ocean using MBARI’s remotely operated vehicles, then watched as the CO2 dissolved and spread.. Peter examined the chemical impacts, and Jim the biological ones. The experiment was relatively crude, Jim says, but it was eye opening: Near the plume, most of the animals died. (It’s notable, Jim added, that below about 350 meters CO2 occurs as a liquid, not a gas.)
Deep-sea animals tend to be more sensitive to change than shallow-water relatives that evolved to cope with variable conditions, Jim says. He began collecting deep-sea Tanner crabs and shallow-dwelling Dungeness crabs, putting them in special holding tanks to compare how they’re responding to an acidifying ocean. While these early experiments used unnaturally high CO2 levels, the results suggested that deep-sea crabs may be less able to cope with the challenges of environmental change they’ll face in the future.
Bringing the lab to the field
Unlike the controlled conditions inside a laboratory, wild nature is complex. Water temperatures, dissolved oxygen levels and acidity rise and fall naturally. These variables complicate the task of measuring the impact of a single variable, such as carbon emissions from burning fossil fuel fuels. Today, MBARI scientists are finding new and innovative ways to address that challenge.
One way to observe changes to the living environment is to bring the lab to the sea floor. The team at MBARI built a suite of tools that include a deep-sea respirometer, which measures an animal’s oxygen consumption, and the Free-Ocean Carbon Enrichment (FOCE) system, which allows researchers to study ecosystem responses to environmental variables.
Some ocean conditions are especially tricky to study. Upwelling regularly bathes coastal habitats with cold, acidic and oxygen-depleted water from the deep, affecting habitats and fisheries. MBARI post-doctoral researcher Charles Boch compares upwelling to an underwater hurricane whose timing and severity are near impossible to predict.
Charles’ studies of ocean acidification on red abalone, conducted with Jim and Hopkins Marine Station resarchers Fiorenza Micheli and Giulio De Leo, show fertilization suffers as acidity increases. Research also shows problems with shell formation in other invertebrates. Understanding how acidity works in concert with other variables, and how those effects ripple throughout entire ecosystems, is critical for resource managers.
Strength in numbers
Research efforts like MBARI’s help inform the search for science-based solutions. By 2012, ocean acidification research had made its way into recommendations to California policy makers.
The Aquarium has partnered with local and state government agencies, as well as with other nonprofits, to take on the challenge. In 2016, we joined the International Alliance to Combat Ocean Acidification, a global network of governments and organizations addressing ocean acidification and other climate-related threats. In July, when the federal government withdrew from the Paris climate accord, California Gov. Jerry Brown announced the state would gather leaders from around the world for a Climate Action Summit in San Francisco, in September 2018.
“Ocean acidification is a rallying point where the ocean community joins with climate change community,” says Aimee David, the Aquarium’s director of ocean conservation policy strategies. “Science is giving us a better understanding of how our carbon emissions are fundamentally altering the ocean. Now, we need to come together as a global community to rethink our use of fossil fuels.”
— Diane Richards